Search the Forums
Options
Keywords search:


Search in Forum...

Search within...

Match...

Antiquity...

Player messages...

Mansions of Madness
A board game of occult horror and mystery for two to five players
Moderator: The Spaniard Topics: 607 | Posts: 3467
Vote for your favorite scenario
Published on 04 January 2013 - 13:26:58

This is a copy/paste from bgg. Sorry for cross-posting.

Some players of MoM have been scoring the scenarii on a remote place of the web (and in a different language). It had been very interesting to read out the results. So here is the poll in english. You can score each scenario that you have played. Scores are between 1 and 5 and include everything (I won't split each scenario into different objectives  ). You can score only some and even score later the ones you have been playing since your last vote.

1 - Not the best ; 2- could be better ; 3- fine ; 4 - good ; 5 - excellent

Score here
and view the results here

I can add other scenarii if necessary. Please note that some players have expressed the will to see the poll expanded to included each objective of each scenario indepently. I will do it, most liekley, in a near furture. For now, I am only interested in a global score. I am especially interested in the score of fan-made scenarios.
 

Page 1 of 1 (7 messages) 1
Reply #1 | Published on 13 February 2013 - 05:29:07

 

Hi guys,
 
Here are the first results
 
 
As you can see, I was not really able to appreciate the scoring of fan-made scenarii, due to a poor number of votes (I only included the ones with 2 votes).
 
If you feel like sharing your opinion to the poll, please go score the scenarios
(I have not included the CotW so far)
 
best
Reply #2 | Published on 14 February 2013 - 11:17:52

Of course, now you need the CotW scenarios:
 

A Cry for Help

The Stars Aligned

The Mind's Veil

The Dunwich Horror

A Matter of Trust

A Matter of Trust (bonus map)

"Ashcan" Pete will take that off your hands when you're done with it.
Charlie Kane would befriend a strangled cat if given the chance.
Finn Edwards has very deep pockets.
Hank Samson does not care that you've mastered time travel.
Lily Chen can punch a hue.
Lola Hayes is the world's best Egyptologist.
Mark Harrigan is very good at hedge mazes.
Michael McGlen has never experienced an earthquake.
Minh Thi Phan makes group hugs empowering.
Patrice Hathaway plays songs you can't get out of your head.
Tommy Muldoon is most qualified to be deputy, yet for some reason nobody want him to be.
Tony Morgan sells meat out of the back of his van.
Ursula Downs can shop at an empty store.
Wendy Adams always wins at hide and seek.
William Yorick has a Bachelor's in Cryptozoology—no wonder he can't find work.
Wilson Richards will paint over anything for a dollar.
Zoey Samaras can torch a fire vampire.

Reply #3 | Published on 14 February 2013 - 23:22:31

Agreed. A Matter of Trust by default for being the first solitaire/cooperative scenario gets my vote.

Otherwise as your poll stands, House of Fears was a very smart and well put together scenario, and gets my vote.

"Some said the thunder called the lurking fear out of its habitation, while others said the thunder was its voice."

H.P. Lovecraft, The Lurking Fear

Reply #4 | Published on 15 February 2013 - 21:01:19

Me and my bro are at the second Forbidden Alchemy scenario now and we need to continue our adventure.  I just got Call of the Wild and I must say this expansion is looking pretty epic!  Love all the addition to the base game and how the scenarios were designed.

Clearly a lot of effort and passion was put into this expansion and it made an awesome game even more awesome!

I'll not be surprise that 2 or 3 scenarios from CotW will make top 5.

Without Signature

Reply #5 | Published on 15 February 2013 - 23:59:39

One thing I would like to see is a multi-objective breakdown. For example, the single best Mansions scenario I own is Green Eyed Boy, but it has to be a specific objective. One other scenarios looks like it would be an okay objective, but one of them is a tragedy of an objective.

Meanwhile, the five Call of the Wild scenarios have effectively one objective each.

"Ashcan" Pete will take that off your hands when you're done with it.
Charlie Kane would befriend a strangled cat if given the chance.
Finn Edwards has very deep pockets.
Hank Samson does not care that you've mastered time travel.
Lily Chen can punch a hue.
Lola Hayes is the world's best Egyptologist.
Mark Harrigan is very good at hedge mazes.
Michael McGlen has never experienced an earthquake.
Minh Thi Phan makes group hugs empowering.
Patrice Hathaway plays songs you can't get out of your head.
Tommy Muldoon is most qualified to be deputy, yet for some reason nobody want him to be.
Tony Morgan sells meat out of the back of his van.
Ursula Downs can shop at an empty store.
Wendy Adams always wins at hide and seek.
William Yorick has a Bachelor's in Cryptozoology—no wonder he can't find work.
Wilson Richards will paint over anything for a dollar.
Zoey Samaras can torch a fire vampire.

Reply #6 | Published on 16 February 2013 - 01:29:29

Tibs said:

One thing I would like to see is a multi-objective breakdown. For example, the single best Mansions scenario I own is Green Eyed Boy, but it has to be a specific objective. One other scenarios looks like it would be an okay objective, but one of them is a tragedy of an objective.

Meanwhile, the five Call of the Wild scenarios have effectively one objective each.

For those who have not played every scenario though may spoil the plot by title alone… unless I suppose you titled simply by Objective A, B, and C.

"Some said the thunder called the lurking fear out of its habitation, while others said the thunder was its voice."

H.P. Lovecraft, The Lurking Fear

Reply #7 | Published on 17 February 2013 - 13:26:57

Yes, that's what I meant. "A" "B" and "C" would do nicely.

"Ashcan" Pete will take that off your hands when you're done with it.
Charlie Kane would befriend a strangled cat if given the chance.
Finn Edwards has very deep pockets.
Hank Samson does not care that you've mastered time travel.
Lily Chen can punch a hue.
Lola Hayes is the world's best Egyptologist.
Mark Harrigan is very good at hedge mazes.
Michael McGlen has never experienced an earthquake.
Minh Thi Phan makes group hugs empowering.
Patrice Hathaway plays songs you can't get out of your head.
Tommy Muldoon is most qualified to be deputy, yet for some reason nobody want him to be.
Tony Morgan sells meat out of the back of his van.
Ursula Downs can shop at an empty store.
Wendy Adams always wins at hide and seek.
William Yorick has a Bachelor's in Cryptozoology—no wonder he can't find work.
Wilson Richards will paint over anything for a dollar.
Zoey Samaras can torch a fire vampire.

Page 1 of 1 (7 messages) 1

© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS